Customs Audit, Investigation & Litigation

"BKL has provided valuable, effective and timely legal advice and litigation services. BKL has also advised us how to improve our IP and trade secrets protection and enforcement strategy from the lessons learned in our IP litigation cases."

- Chambers & Partners Asia-Pacific

Overview

A customs audit conceptually corresponds to a tax audit of internal taxes. However, the scope of items subject to review in a customs audit is far wider than a tax audit, because a customs audit includes review of the appropriateness in the overall satisfaction of relevant import/export requirements, such as customs valuation, origin, HS classification, import/export clearance requirements, and foreign exchange. In addition, based on the results of such customs audit, administrative litigation (customs imposition, correctional measures, etc.), penalty fine appeals, criminal litigation, or other litigation procedures will follow.

Diversification in litigation due to a rise in customs-related issues

Recently, in the areas of customs and international trade, there are new tax issues before due to increase in trades among multinational corporations, increasing number of FTAs, and emergence of new trade products (such as virtual currency) and emergence of a trade deal structure combined with new financial techniques. In light of this situation, the audit power of the customs authorities has expanded and strengthened. Also, customs-related disputes have not been limited to traditional issues such as customs valuation but have been expanding to various other topics.

Strengthened foreign exchange inspections/investigations

Increase in trade deal size has resulted in a steep increase in the size of foreign exchange transactions. This has resulted in a growing need to regulate violations of the Foreign Exchange Transaction Act, price manipulation, offshore property transfers, and hiding of criminal proceeds. Accordingly, the Korea Customs Service has recently strengthened foreign exchange inspections/investigations and expanded its organization (including establishing the Foreign Exchange Investigation Division within regional customs offices and increasing relevant staff members). As a result, criminal and administrative disputes in the area of foreign exchange transactions are expected to significantly increase in the future.

Key Services

Customs audits and appeals
Assistance in defending (periodic, special) customs audits
Assistance with examination/disposition deliberation committee hearings and review of adequacy of duty imposition
Representation in appeals against customs duty impositions or penalty impositions resulting from customs audits (Tax Tribunal/administrative litigation)
Responding to foreign exchange inspections/investigations
Assistance in defending foreign exchange inspection/investigation
Representation in penalty fine appeals and criminal proceedings

Representative Cases

Assisted a European industrial machine manufacturing company in a customs evasion investigation related to the import of laser welding machine
The first Supreme Court judgment that specified the illegality of a customs authority’s imposition of customs duties based on duplicated audits
Case involving a fine for negligence for violation of the Foreign Exchange Transaction Act in connection with virtual currency arbitrage
Customs audits
Assisted a European industrial machine manufacturing company in a customs evasion investigation related to the import of laser welding machine
Assisted a Korean company in responding to a customs audit for alleged smuggling and false declarations involving exportation of cosmetics products to China
Assisted a Korean ship operator in responding to a customs audit for alleged omission of import declaration for bareboat charter
Assisted a multinational IT company in responding to audit for alleged smuggling based on the omission of import declaration for material used in the research and development of medical products
Assisted a Korean company in responding to an audit for illegal importation based on wood pellet importers’ omission of wood size/quality inspections
Litigation
The first Supreme Court judgment that specified the illegality of a customs authority’s imposition of customs duties based on duplicated audits
The first court judgment that customs and VAT shall not be imposed on the grounds that the omission of a shipping-out declaration in transferring foreign goods between bonded factories was considered smuggling
Case involving a fine for negligence for violation of the Foreign Exchange Transaction Act in connection with virtual currency arbitrage
Lawsuit for appropriateness of customs value of medical device imported by a multinational medical device company
Tax Tribunal case with respect to whether various crude oils used in oil refining process constituted the same raw material, the object of refund under the Act on Special Cases Concerning the Refund of Customs Duties, Etc. Levied on Raw Materials for Export